The Arguments Against Introducing Coaching

Despite the compelling reasons we might offer for introducing coaching we can expect to encounter many barriers. We need to understand what the barriers are and how we might help others develop their understanding of coaching so that these barriers may be removed.

We've got enough on our plate as it is

Most organizations these days seem to be working at the edge of chaos. Change is abundant and managers are rightly worried that one more change will prove to be 'the straw that breaks the camels back'. Seen in this way, coaching, as just one more stand-alone initiative, is bound to take a back seat. But coaching should not be seen in this way. Coaching can be the glue that binds change initiatives together. After all, we know that all change programmes have a people element and that if staff and other stakeholders are not carefully guided through the changes, failure is quite likely.

Where managers are equipped with good coaching skills they are able to assist their staff in comprehending both the underlying reasons for change and the unsettling feelings that result. More importantly managers who coach will be able to empower their teams to find their own coping strategies rather than crowbar them into prescriptive methods that usually provoke rebellion rather than commitment.

Now is not the right time

If people are claiming this then, paradoxically, it is absolutely the right time for coaching. Good, effective coaching raises awareness, generates responsibility and builds trust. There is never any sense in delaying having access to these qualities.

If we leave coaching until 'other things have settled down' it's like saying we'll put the umbrellas up once it's stopped raining.

Our Team Leaders have a high level of skill anyway

No doubt this is true, but skills need to be developed and adapted to emerging trends and changes.

Coaching, it seems, is one of the skills of management that is expected to manifest itself in the manager by some kind of osmosis. In other words the expectation is that of course managers can coach - they're managers! But again this is not the case. Whilst most managers would claim that they undertake coaching, few would be able to offer a precise definition of the term or differentiate coaching from counselling, teaching, mentoring or most other forms of people development. However, as we've seen coaching is quite different; essentially it is about helping people learn rather than teaching them things. Learning to coach requires guidance and practise. It is not difficult but it is a very potent intervention that can cause problems if used carelessly.

We would not let our Team Leaders loose on a new IT system without proper training so why let them loose on their teams?

It will cost too much

Much depends on how the costs are calculated. Whilst there is an up front investment of time and money in having managers and team leaders trained as coaches this can be saved over and over again by the consequent improvements in team performance.

Compare the cost of one manager being trained as a coach so that he/she can help the team members become effective at personal organization against the cost of sending the whole team on time management courses.

Deciding whether we should implement coaching in an organization can be compared with clearing a forest. Do we stop from time to time to sharpen the axe and clear the forest more quickly and effectively in the end or do we keep hacking away with a blunt blade so that we can 'just get to the end of this next tree'?

© Matt Somers, 2009. Reprints welcome so long as by-line and article are published intact and all links made live.

Matt Somers - Coaching Skills Training

About The Author:

Matt Somers is the author of Coaching at Work (John Wiley & Sons, 2006) and Instant Manager: Coaching (Hodder & Stoughton, 2008). His consultancy practice is focused on helping managers become coaches and achieve the results that coaching promises.

If you liked this article, then you'll love Matt's Coaching Secrets newsletter with it's fortnightly blast of up to date hints and tips. Click Here and register today!

 

Please register me for the 'Coaching Secrets' Newsletter

Name
Email
Enter your main email address above and receive a complimentary subscription to my coaching skills training newsletter (worth £100 per year).

You'll receive regular updates with valuable information on coaching skills training for managers. You can unsubscribe at any time - but I hope you won't want to!

Your privacy is vital to us so your details will never be sold, given, traded or rented to anyone else. 

 Coaching Skills Training and Coaching Skills for Managers Coaching books